Mafia III , The begining of the end :)

Wave is innocent.

I am innocent.

any other theory is incorrect.

Why? Because neither of us would have missed that first night's deadline.
Also because Lynching Godling was then, and is now the right thing to do. Thus not scummy.

that is all.

Ok this is my major suspect list based off of when and how people posted.

SW because he didn't pop on until the mafia actually killed and is being far more vocal than he was last game and also voted for no lynch when he did finally make it on.

IrishRose because she is new and been very quiet and would have been very likely to not know what to do if her other mafia friends where lurking.

I don't think Camn or Wave are scum since they both have lots of experience playing this game and wouldn't go with a no mafia kill if one of their own was a lurker.

those are my strongest reads so far and i'll fill in the list better after i can get a better feel of everyone else.

EDIT that's not fair Camn i was writing that same theory as you and yours posted first

well i think perhaps some things may be plauseable,,

1) you are the cop, and a confused cop so you investigated wave nite one and and got an innocent verdict
or you investigated me and got and got a guilty wich i am innocent

2) you are not he cop and are trying to imply that you are to protect him (since doc dead) and since waves logic has been close to yours you assume wave is innocent and since most of the board already thinks i am scum you might as well vote for godling he comes up scum and i must be scum and i am too new to make the deadline since game one i was scum but i had help this time you think that i don't and i missed the deadline since i couldn't get ahold of my scummy budies,

so yah thats what i think

Tubby, I think you are town.
I have no "verdicts", just logic.

Now.. who should we lynch?
You have a double vote.... and I am willing to let Godling ride for a little bit.

What is your opinion on Sypher?

c

I don't think tubby216 is Mafia, either. I doubt he would make himself
such a big target over trying to save his friend if he were. However
I'm already sick of godling's name (not your fault, godling).

We'll see what happens with more voting coming in. I might change my vote, but not quite yet.

Here's where I'm at....and who I feel could be on the dark side.....

SW for the reason the first night deadline was missed also fiend suspects him, who's instincts are usually pretty sound.

Irishrose cos again she missed the deadline and hasn't voted at all although she has been here and had the opportunity to do so.

Godling cos again he wasnt here.

Adrian cos he's been on camn's case since day 1 until he votes for tubby today but he could be innocent because he wouldnt have let the deadline pass on day1.

The people I feel are innocent are....

Camn cos his vote swinging day1 ensured discussion also would not have let the kill deadline pass.

Wave and tubby cos they wouldn't have missed the deadline either.

If the deadline was missed on purpose then most of the above could be bollocks. Would they be so sneeky to miss a deadline on purpose to cover their arses now ? Personally I doubt it.

It's a pity we don't know how many scumm are out there because our cop won't know when to come forward with any known results. He/she is gambling with their life now cos if they have just one guilty verdict it's a gamble keeping that to themselves incase they get offed at night.

So for today, I'm going to follow fiend's advice and vote SW.

Vote StatelyWayne

yah dj is suspect, i mena he has been pretty scattered brained and all over the place

i'll post more later

ok heres my suspects.....

dj sypher... cause as tubby said hes scattered.. usually he has pretty good logic, 2nd i could see him misisng deadline.

Adrain...cause hes agreeing with sypher.. when what he said really didnt make much since.

so if i end up dead tonight...we know why...

vote dj sypher

I am interested in a Sypher Lynch.

Godling.. your opinion?

:O ok... yes i have been scatter brained...mhm and i suspect tubby mainly because he choose to lay down and die... if he is town why not jus say ok look yeah i messed up im innocent though...

ok now for my own defence...

iv'e now been in 3 games(this being the third) all the mods know this and if i was mafia i wouldnt have me open my mouth... id be stumped... being innocent is easy but to be fair im a rubbish liar...

and if you end up dead crystal id be supprised... lets face it ur landing a lynching on an innocent... im the scatter brained one who doesnt want the town to lose twice in a row hence im not saying hell lynch me i dont care as tubby is... mhm ok ok so my list in order...

tubby
kist
adrian

anyone dissagree....

I disagree.

Quote :

iv'e now been in 3 games(this being the third) all the mods know this and if i was mafia i wouldnt have me open my mouth... id be stumped... being innocent is easy but to be fair im a rubbish liar...

This makes no sense.
Roles are selected randomly. the mod has nothing to do with it. and the Mafia HAS been playing poorly. You HAVE had your mouth closed.

And tubby is obviously town. No scum would act so obviously scummy

c

here is what i think,
dj sypher-is a lil too quick to vote for me, also he posted after the proxy vote was explained then said that he understood where i where i come from and never changed his vote, he also has been on sparaticly, yes and the mafia has been awful noobish and if you re read the mafia kills the hint is tward male mafia members,

the mafia member preforming the kill said "brothers" when the mafia killed dustin it was said "he" took a sip of the wiskey,

wave (see shield theroy) and its possible that he could not get ahold of his two noob mafia budies and the mod wants a vote , i also feel he got ahold of sypher and they finally got a vote, i think if we cut off the head we kill the snake, I know camn is not gonna like this and wave will defend himself callin me crazy, but wave has never defended himself so hard but yet sit back and happily alow camn to do his thinkin for him so

short list
wave
dj sypher


in my defense alow me this quote,

" caught in the action of kill or be killed greater love hath no man than to lay down his life for a friend" ~ Kris Kristofferson 8th of novemember by Big and Rich


vote wave

kist proxy vote wave

You guys are starting to annoy me... I have been the most coherent player so far...

Instead of following a cooking recipe and just say, let's start voting lurkers, no matter who they are, and then we start doing math and ask the cop to come out... NO! I have TWO SUSPECTS and I'm only voting for them and I will until the end of the game or until I'm dead.

So nobody can accuse me of "agreeing with" anybody or vote-switching or not making sense. If you ask me about something I already said, fine, I'll repeat myself, but my actions are straightforward as an arrow.

Besides, anybody that says that another player is innocent without having a good suspect is just wasted keystrokes... How can we know if ANYBODY is innocent.

btw, I'll repeat myself... I'm convinced they missed the deadline on purpose. So unless the Mod said that she had to hear from all mafia members, it was done on purpose.

I'll bet anything that at least one mafia member is an experienced player.

well as last game proved i have a very hard time reading DJ. I could definately see him being scum but i have a bad track record when it comes to him but i wouldn't be against voting for him by any means. just so long as we don't end up with a tie vote i'm down.

Whoa!

now that godling it back with us.

Unvote
Vote DJ Sypher

VOTE COUNT


Godling - 1 (Wave)
Tubby - 2 (Sypher, Adrian)
Wave - 2 (Tubby, AnrKissed)
Sypher - 2 (camn, crystal)
Wayne - 1 (Stimp)

The plot thickens!
Get voting people!



c

My apologies, Stimp!

@tubby216

Where did you come up with this idiotic idea that the Mod is getting the Mafia to vote for the night kill? The vote is for lynching. Someone from the Mafia PM's the Mod the night kill. One PM, not a vote. You are proclaiming that the rules might have been changed to substantiate your theory. Why don't you build your theories around the existing rules instead of rearranging the rules to fit your theories? Jeez, godling is finally in the game and you are still annoying the hell out of me.

First there were a handful of seasoned players around on the first night's happenings. Anrkissed has already pointed this out along with who was there. How hard would it have been for myself or any of these other players, yes camn was one as well, to send a PM by the deadline considering that we can all type or we wouldn't be playing this game in the first place?

Secondly I'd like to point out that your friend that you kept protecting was one of those not around, you know, like Zane. I switched my vote yesterday from godling to Zane because it looked to me that he would be the popular lurker vote and perhaps to some degree to get you to stop going on about it. I could care less what lurker goes as long as they all do.

I think we have one or two inexperienced players on the Mafia (well Zane was Mafia, inexperienced, and a lurker) and perhaps another one or two that may have experience, but that might not have been around in time for the deadline the first night. Now that is just a theory, but one based on logic.

We have to concentrate on the players who were not around for the deadline and who among those may by guilty.

You are still pissed at camn and I because we had the nerve to vote for your precious friend who could very well be Mafia, btw. Why don't you clear your head and start thinking logically?

@Camn
....
Please make your vote tallies accurate......

I clearly voted for statelywayne!

ok ok lets think about that... gtosdad lurking and then as soon as the heat looks like its off apears(POOF) jus like magic....lol...
all i ask for is a fair trial... i know its early days but give me a chance to warm back up...

Come on, DJ. You gotta come up with something better than that for a defense... "warming up"... jeeze...


TALLY
Godling = 1 (Wave)
Tubby = 2 (Sypher, Adrian)
Wave = 2 (Tubby, AnrKissed)
Sypher = 2 (camn, crystal)
SW = 1 (Stimp)

4 people still to vote.

Dj Sypher wrote:

ok ok lets think about that... gtosdad lurking and then as soon as the heat looks like its off apears(POOF) jus like magic....lol...
all i ask for is a fair trial... i know its early days but give me a chance to warm back up...

What does this even mean?

c

wave are you high???

i stopped pokin at camn this morning,,

i also stopped protecting "my friend" since he showed up and mett my deadline,

by the way i ws not pissed at at camn or you for votes i just wanted you to listen to my pleas,

i always come out hard agianst camn, camn likes to point fingers and call people out i like to blast him and force other people either to get with me or show why they think other wise, camn is a very good expeirence player and i feel he can defend himself well enough to pokes hole back at me and in that way we figure out whose who,

but who however have a weak defense and are content to hide behind camn and eggin on camn to blast me back ,, its almost like you are be hind him jumping and yelling yah what that guy said and wispering in his ear ,, yah get that guy hes got nothin he's scummy,, knowing full well your the dirty one,

as fae as trhe voting thing maybe i am wrong i have no clue but if adrian's theroy is correct and you add in that perhaps the other scummies are noobs and half lurking perhaps that "seasoned " player decided to for go the vote to better train his peeps

but i have said all i can say everyone and their brother knows what i think

Adrian, thanks for the tally, but it looks ugly. It's looks like a perfect Mafia tally of confusion.

I don't want a tie, so I'll pull my vote for

Unvote godling since I see that someone else has, but not because of the above post or anything, but because I don't want to help in splitting the whole vote like it's going.

And I'll see where the chips go to at least avoid a tie.

sorry wave i throw the bs flag

but thanks for helping out my point of view,

cause although you changed your vote you did admit that there is an uncanny trend between you and camn

so yah go ahead save us all because you pulled your vote, if you think i am so wrong why didn't you go ahead and vote for me? since i am so wierding out and acting sooo scummy?? that would have ended the three way tie??? or do you wann just kill me off tonite and get your hands dirty cause you wanna savor the kill, make it all bloody and show the town that n one messes with the great wave??

This is fun!

With all the bickering and the back and forth arguments.

If on top of that I'm right about my suspicions... What a sweet game this will be for me...

Wave: by just unvoting you are not really helping anything... Why don't you vote for tubby with me? Or maybe tubby can vote camn like yesterday and we can both follow him!

TALLY
Tubby = 2 (Sypher, Adrian)
Wave = 2 (Tubby, AnrKissed)
Sypher = 2 (camn, crystal)
SW = 1 (Stimp)

It's pointless arguing with someone all night, tubby216. I knew you'd think that it was bs about unvoting godling as well I thought you'd think the same thing about me following camn. I did not follow him if you think about it. I left the vote godling trend which was diminishing. But that's not how you are going to think of it and whatever.

I don't think that you'd miss a mafia kill deadline hanging around like you were the first night. That's why I don't vote for you. You can consider that bs as well as everything I say obviously is. Keep your vote(s). I'm in pain.

Sheesh, I try to help the guy get off the godling thing for his own good and look what I get