Mafia III , The begining of the end :)

I WAS just getting to like them!

And my theory is consistent. But I hate a town that gets in a rut. We need discussion.
Besides, what if the day goes by, and Everybody posts "hello!" Then what are we left with? No Information, and no Likely Candidates

And anyway, 12 hours does not a lurker make.

That said.. Tubby.. I may be bloodthirsty.. but I'm no fool!
I hate lurkers.. but we can't let a lurkerhunt stop us from finding SCUM!

Unvote
Vote: TC

For ridiculous circular logic.

lol @ wave.....



edit to add.....

CAMN ur off the hook already??? how u jus gonna go enated to lynch people for dumb logic? r u outta meds hun? lol

camn wrote:

Hello, My friends.

All Lurkers Must Die.

hmmmm... Pretty solid vote for killing lurkers

camn wrote:

Of course... if we all just post "i'm in" , then vote for a lurker...
that gives us as little to work with as a no-lynch.
Discussion is key. A Simple HI will not suffice.

Hmmmm... change of heart?

Why do you always have to be so suspicious camn! Grrr.

I know how you all feel about my favorite nolynch strategy for the first round, so I wont even try it. No lurkers is a pretty solid tactic for the first round as well. Lurkers benefit the mafia slighty more. Reason being they are dead weight at the end of the game.

Lets stick around and see who is lurking. That will force people to pipe up. Full participation is key for a good game

ouch i see how it is hang the new guy huh

and if they are lurking they aren't voting so killing them at the present time wouldn't be benificial right ? i dunno i'm new don't mind me..

OK.. All fun stimulation aside... here is my reasoning.

I hate lurkers. They ruin the game. ESPECIALLY the endgame.

BUT

the game just started. It sucks if you pick it up tonight and you are already dead.

To me a lurker is one of 2 things:

A) someone who simply doesn't post, for days, and we can't count on them to help us when votes get tight. They aren't really playing, and throw off the math, thus wrecking the game.

AND/OR

B) Someone who posts.. but doesn't post anything of substance or content. They are VERY scummy, imo, and must die.

Thus.. if we all simply ACCEPT a no-lynch, or a die-lurker-die right here at the outset... it turns ALL of us into category B lurkers.
In which case we all must die. Thus I am against SITTING AROUND AND WAITING... because then, they are us.

So.. for day 1, I would rather see a battle than just passively wait to see who fits a certain "criteria". I will kill lurkers later. When it is painfully clear who they are.

Thus
unvote
Vote: NOLYNCH

this day is too short to figure out who the scum are.


edit for doublepost

hmmm if had to leave and i wouldnt be back ny deadline i'd leave my vote...

maybe thats just me...

Alright, so far the lurkers are (using the game mod's order of players):

- Zane
- gtosdad
- Anrkissed
- statelywayne
- godling

I know that godling has been on this site today, so his official break from being called lurker is obviously over.

**Edit to say, can we get rid of the poll now? Lol.

I may not be around to vote later on so I will cast my vote now for Gtosdad I have no real reason except hes always really quiet and difficult to get a read on and somehow he always manages to sneak under the radar until the end of the game and at that point I never know what to make of him, so no offense I got nothing against you but since it's day 1 and we have nothing to go on in an effort to avoid future confusion

VOTE: Gtosdad

I'm with you.

Gtod has ALWAYS been a lurker.. yet somehow survives to screw us in the end
I used him to my advantage last game.

Unvote
Vote Gtosdad

And then you wonder why you're always in the spotlight, camn!!

You not only vote right away but then switch votes THREE TIMES and like stirring the pot. In a game about dying and surviving you run around the room screaming "look at me, look at me" and every once in a while you say something that makes sense... Like the saying "you know enough (of this game) just to be dangerous" so that's why you are always a target.

Yup.

see my vote stands ,,, i feel camn is more dangerous in a game that kist atleast kist is predicabley unpredicable,,, camn just seem like he is bi-polar gone astray,,,

so yah i think camn needs lynched ,, he probably has better things to do today,,,

You think I'M dangerous?

If you are Mafia, I am.

c

I'll go with gtosdad if that will be the general consensus. But I'll wait because we may still hear from some of the 'to-date' lurkers.

Current Vote Tally:

Camn = 1 (tubby216)
Gtosdad = 2 (Dustin, camn)

how the heck you figure that,, you had eveyone convinced but me last time that you were innocent and then you waste everyone in the final scene,,, you my friend are scummie

"If you are Mafia, I am."

WHAT THE HELL WAS THAT???

I have no idea where this is coming from. I think these two (camn and tubby) are bickering to make us believe that they are townies or they would be laying low.

I am sure that they are both mafia. And I'm willing to bet upload credit on it... Oh, wait... This is not TuneBully anymore...

Jokes aside... Camn is more volatile than ever and that's suspicious to me and tubby has never "picked" on anybody before, and that's also fishy for me.

I'll prove it by jumping on tubby's vote and see if he switches it... If everybody says we have no info and any theory is as good as any, then vote with me and see what happens...

VOTE CAMN

see exactly,, but i guess i sjhould explain my reasoning for jumpin om camn so quick,

1) i am still bitter about last gamei had my gut feeling and diddn't have enough proof and it has been eating at me all game.

2) he was to quick to start a vote claiming people has got to go ,, then he switches his votes more times than a hooker switches condoms,

therfore unreliable and if he is playin scatter brained its a new staragy tryin to hide his scummieness

so yah i am playin a lil more aggresively than last game but i was highly active last game too ( i think i had the majority of posts lol)

so thers my opinion but i could be wrong

my vote stands

I'm ok with that, tubby... Now let's see if peeps follow us in lynching Camn.

okie dokie

vote Tally

Gtosdad = 2 (Camn, Dustin)
Camn = 2 (Tubby, Adrian)

Come on people! 12 more to vote!!!

To answer your question adrian.. I see it came out a little wrong I didn't mean If Tubby is Mafia, I am mafia.. I meant, if Tubby is Mafia, I am Dangerous.

Tubby.. you shouldn't vote for anyone based on Last game. That's poor reasoning.
And regarding reason 2.. I never claimed anyone HAD TO GO. Just threw some votes out there. I'd like to see everyone else do the same!

I am playing pretty wild. I want discussion.. not rote-day-one algorithms. Plus.. I love this game! Plus.. you think I don't KNOW that this would buy me some votes? If I were scum... why would I be so crazy?! I just happen to have the day off

no i get your stargey if you wanna call it one,, and it calls for the player to walk a fine line trying to provoke people into showing their true colors,, the only problem with you trying to play this way only makes you look scummier,, as far as playin out of revenge its not toatly like that what i meant by that was i was not goin to let anyone sway my vote, when you were a townie yes you were scumm hunting heavy, but you diddn't make wild accusations either, you were had it down with pinpoint accuracy, when you were a scummie you were confusing and muddying the waters, this is the play i think you are makin now, if anything with you are just cementing my views with every post.

sorry but thats the way i feel

You don't have to be sorry. Just remember your feelings of certainty when I flip town! And you havn't played with me enough to TOTALLY have my game down.. Now where is Stimp?!

Anyway.. the only way to Hunt effectively is to have discussion. If I were scum I would be playing low and easy at first. Confusing LATER.
Plus, I don't think I am actually confusing anything right now. Are you confused? Have I seriously ACCUSED anyone? Nope. You and Adrian are the only ones to launch accusations so far. So that argument doesn't really work, either.

But I appreciate you and Adrian, because you aren't afraid to get in here and get dirty. . . and we are starting to see who the lurkers really are, no?

or we are simply seeing who has no life and ALOT of time on their hands,,,lol


but i still think you are scummie,, yup scummie cause why wouldn't you change you game up i mean you have played how many games with these people?? 4 maybe 5 and you are callin on your previous playing style to prove you innocence?? hmm seem afully clever to me chum

so yup i am saying you are scum

tubby216 wrote:

or we are simply seeing who has no life and ALOT of time on their hands,,,lol

TOTALLY!!

Anyway.. you'll see. At some point during this game you will find out the truth.

c