Mafia 16 - Raby Castle-TOWN WINS!!!

fine she posted


unvote

You can speculate all you want about the roles but I've said as much as I'm going to.

Current vote count
Wave -1- (Kist)
Godling -2- (Howard, Dustin)
Crystal -1- (Lamont)

Guido Capone wrote:

Oh one question Mod.... Docs, Cops, and Baddies or other roles, how many if any, or is it a blind guessing game at this point.

Does anyone find it suspicious that Guido asked for the number of roles? Am I right in thinking that this knowledge would help the Mafi more than the village? It is almost like a Mafi asking for the additional number of village roles so they would know...

FoS Guido

Unvote, Vote Godling

Okay, that makes only one lurker, at least up until this point.

Vote Godling

Wave wrote:

Okay, that makes only one lurker, at least up until this point.

Yes I agree. There are several that only said "hi".

I realize there are still 6 hours left until night but I would like to say that if Godling remains the only lurker that would be good for the Mafi because its an easy BW and very little info will be revealed D1.

I suppose the benefit of ridding the village of a lurker outwieghs the lack of info and there IS a 25% chance he's Mafi...

Yes, you have to at least make one post. Lurkers go first usually. People get busy in r/l. And my internet connection was down from the start of the game until late afternoon of the first day.

@ Lamont,

guido said this:

Guido Capone wrote:

Oh one question Mod.... Docs, Cops, and Baddies or other roles, how many if any, or is it a blind guessing game at this point.

then your reply an hour later was this

Lamont_Cranston wrote:

Ya, good point. It would be at least good to know how many "made" players there are out there...

Certainly we have a minimum of two and a maximum of four.

I'm betting its going to be 2 or 3...

at this point it seems you agree with his setiment that knowing alittle more about prespective roles would be helpful.


then we get this further fishing gem here

Lamont_Cranston wrote:

I'm sorry that I must pick this apart:

wildirishrose wrote:

There are 6 roles and 6 townies.

Am
I to take this to mean that we have 3 Mafi & 9 townies and that of
the 9 townies there are 3 power roles & that of the 3 Mafi there
are 3 power roles? (I formulate this based on a simple notion of
"keeping things even" as Rose has previously stated)

So:

6 Vanillagers
3 Power village
3 Power mafi

Would this be correct?

Lamont_Cranston wrote:

Guido Capone wrote:

Oh one question Mod.... Docs, Cops, and Baddies or other roles, how many if any, or is it a blind guessing game at this point.

Does anyone find it suspicious that Guido asked for the number
of roles? Am I right in thinking that this knowledge would help the
Mafi more than the village? It is almost like a Mafi asking for the
additional number of village roles so they would know...

FoS Guido

Unvote, Vote Godling

then to top it all off you try to lay this all at guido's feet,, i believe it is you sir who is stuck in a recurring role on "deadliest Catch" and deserve to b e lynched for it.


vote Lamont

tubby216 wrote:

@ Lamont,

[b]at this point it seems you agree with his setiment that knowing alittle more about prespective roles would be helpful.

I appreciate the fact you are paying attention here but I find your logical flaws disturbing. My question is about the number of MAFIA players whereas his request dealt with the total number of roles.

then to top it all off you try to lay this all at guido's feet,, i believe it is you sir who is stuck in a recurring role on "deadliest Catch" and deserve to be lynched for it.

More very poor logic. The first response you quoted from me was BEFORE Rose responded. At that time I noted his request for the number of roles and logged it as suspicious but decided to hold my tongue.

Then she posted her answer (I disagree with her doing this by the way). Once the info was out it is the village that is at the disadvantage as the Mafia have a much greater ability to determine the roles than the village does. There is no doubt that they will in night chat and so since the info was released I picked it apart for the village to determine HOW MANY Mafia roles there were.

If it is anyone then that should get your vote it is Guido for actually asking for the roles!

So, why do you feel the need to accuse me instead??

Unvote, Vote Guido

FoS Tubby

no my logic is fine and now you are floundering scum caught in your own web of misdirection,


rose said there were six roles

so there could be anywhere from 6 to 1 scum, or there could be two teams of two or 1 team of 2 and an SK,

it could be any possibility, its our job to find them,

i believe you have made some slips and you are scum and need lynched

but we get more information from the lynch and the nite kills more than anything else,,

hell if you want to lynch me , at this point it doesn't matter who gets lynched, we have an undefined number of scum and undefined number of townie roles

Tubby what exactly is my slip? The Mafi aren't stupid.

The cause of this info being released was not me it was Guido and you misinterpreting the whole situation is not helping and I find it disturbing.

I hate how this site won't quote properly and I hope Crystal fixes it.

Are you serious!? Who cares who gets lynched??

With an attitude like that it ought to be you!

I am a hairs breadth from switching my vote to you for that terrible attitude.

I would like some advice on Tubby Meta. Would he have this much courage as a Mafi to make such a statement? Or is it HE that has been caught?

no its just a game and i seriously don't care if I get lynched, we will learn far more from tonites nite actions results then we will with who wagoned who on day one

so yah grow a spine an vote me for i have no problem with calling for more votes on you

I'm sorry but I think your attack on me is badly applied logic. I think your case applies much better for Guido, hence my vote there.

If someone can come up with appropriate meta for you suggesting you would act this way as Mafi then I will gladly change my vote but until then I think you're village -- I don't think you would dare do this as Mafi.

tic toc tic toc,,


come on post something all the cool kids are doing it why aren't you???

current vote count

Wave -1- (Kist)
Godling -3- (Howard, Dustin, Wave)
Lamont -1- (Tubby)
Guido -1- (Lamont)

Deadline in 56 minutes

Still to vote
Luckie
Nicolet
Epod
Godling
Guido
Crystal

I am here for the final hour.

Of the lurker list:

Luckie
Nicolet
Epod
Godling
Guido
Crystal

The following have posted no real content:

Luckie, Nicolet, Epod, Godling, Crystal

What this actually means I am not quite sure but data it is.

LOL I just read this and it means only Guido has said anything game related. haha!

Ok so don't tell the nurses but I finally got a blackberry into the hospital. I have a kidney stone to large to pass and I'm hooked up to a morphine drip at the moment so its not the best circumstances but here I am trying anyway. If you all still vote me I understand. My procedure is tomorrow and I will be home but not sure how coherent I will be. For now I would like to
VOTE HOWARD
Since he picked me first to vote for and I'm town. This also makes me suspect crystal. Like I said I understand if anyone still votes for me I just felt I owed it to the town to try and post instead of letting the mafia take down a townie for free
(Sorry on a phone so I can't change the vote color).

Wow Godling my prayers are with you.

The reason we all voted for you is because players who are inactive hurt the village as it makes it harder to find Mafi and sometimes Mafi even use it as a technique to avoid village attention for lynching.

How do you weigh in on Guido asking for the number of power roles in this game?

At 8:30pm I state this: Godling, you have not answered my query and I really need more input from you before I can change my vote.

Anyone on the lurker list is worth my vote but Howard it is definitely not worthy of a vote from anyone imo.

ok i am calling it now

before goddling is lynched that the scum team is at very least lamont howard and crystal, so if there is a vig target one of those three if i die tonite

LMAO @ Tubby!

I'm not toally happy with the Godling lynch but I don't think we can change it at this point unless we get some village participation and quickly.

Ouch!! Good luck, Godling.

Too late for any change, I guess.

Ya I know why they voted for me. That's why I went after howard
He picked me over crystal
Other people explained why
But it could only
Be one of three reasons
1 They are partners
2 He feels bad for her subjecting herself to the first day lurker frenzy
3 Or he flipped a coin
Lamont seems guilty but I think its still the over aggresive manner he picked up from other games
Guido doesn't seem suspicious for asking something we all wondered

Ya what there is like 1 minute left?

Yes of course we all wonder how many power roles there are but we DON'T ask about it!!!

sry had to vote that way i have been @ the hospital with godling, i had a chance to skim what was posted and i agreed with Tubby.